Trusting in Love by Chantel Rhondeau

Paige Warren has always followed the rules, only to discover some should be broken. Anthony Bledsoe loves her deeply but discovers he can’t trust her. Can the magic of McCallister’s Paradise bring these two together or are their pasts too difficult to reconcile?
Diving guide Paige Warren dreams of helping her disabled brother experience the joys of deep-water diving. An accidental pregnancy followed by catching her cheating fiancé sends her into a tailspin, farther from her dreams than she’s ever been. Can she be a mother? Should she? Worse, what will happen to her brother if she selfishly chooses a different life plan?
Coworker Anthony Bledsoe has secretly loved Paige for three long years. He’s longed for her to leave the jerk of a fiancé who won’t move to McCallister’s Paradise to support her dreams. Anthony’s the one who’s always had her back and been by her side through the dangers they face during a workday. However, learning more about Paige’s life clashes with his own, and Anthony wonders if love is enough. He can’t trust Paige, and maybe he’s been lying to himself about love this entire time.
It will take more than McCallister’s Paradise’s brand of magic for a wounded woman and a cynical man to learn to trust in love.