Perfect Gem by Lynn Hagen

A one-off in a club bathroom should have been it. A good time and amazing memories. To say Gem was shocked to see the stud show up at the coffee shop where he worked was an understatement. Now Grey has set his sights on Gem, and Gem wasn’t sure what to think. His boyfriend of two years dumped him for a shinier new model, and Gem was still licking his wounds, but when he discovered that things are not what they seem in Willow Point, Gem found himself running right into Grey’s strong, nonhuman arms.

Grey had been kicking himself for a week for not getting his mate’s name or phone number. He hadn’t realized Gem was his until after the human had hauled it out of the bathroom of The Manacle and split before Grey could find him. Now Gem was in his town, right under Grey’s nose the entire time, and there was a lethal threat after him.