Paper Butterflies by Michelle Chamberland

Neil Summers is a preacher’s son.
Religious, pure, off-limits.
Especially for Olivia—who only wants to defile and corrupt him.

On the first day back to school after summer break, seventeen-year-old Olivia Davis finds herself gawking at Neil—yes, gawking. Ugh. Wholesome, kind, and holy Neil; the son of a preacher, Neil. But she can’t put her finger on what it is, exactly, that’s different about him. Broader shoulders, suddenly more chiseled features, and a new haircut, sure, but it’s something else. Maybe it’s the way he now carries himself, full of calm and confidence. Maybe it’s the memories they share of being childhood best friends.
Or maybe… it’s the look in his eyes that screams he might not be so wholesome after all.