Keyed Up by Diane Michaels

Katie should be in heaven. After nursing a broken heart while cooking in a soulless chain restaurant, her new job as head chef at a Catskills resort is the change she needs. But why would anyone entrust her with a kitchen when she can’t even manage a set of keys?
Good thing she lives next door to a locksmith.
Kenny churns out spares faster than she loses them. But being alone together always leaves them tongue-tied.
The small town’s gossips propose a cure for the two neighbors’ shyness: falling in love.
Just not with each other.
When every blind date the women arrange is as horrible as the latest review of the restaurant and Katie’s biggest secret becomes public knowledge, she’s ready to hide from everyone. Especially Kenny.
Except he has other plans.
He needs help with his own crisis. Can teaching him to believe in himself be the key to Katie learning to trust herself?