His Boy to Hold by G.R. Lyons

Dear Santa,
I’m an impulsive guy. Always have been. Even writing this letter was a snap decision. But when I make a choice, I see it through and never look back. Being like this has served me well in every area of my life.
Except when it comes to love.
I feel silly writing this letter when I can’t even have what I want—but now that I’ve started, I can’t stop—so if I could have one thing for Christmas, it would be to have someone to get to know. Slowly. Properly. I want someone who will come to Daddy with all their hopes, dreams, and passions and let me nurture it all.
I want someone to hold.
Scott-Free
A magical one-night stand feels like love at first sight, but Everett Scott has made that mistake before and he got the divorce to show for it. Besides, Everett is straight. One night with a perfect boy had to be a fluke.
Everett turns to online dating, hoping to learn to take things slow, but the only intriguing response to his letter is from BoyToHold. The more they talk, the more Everett starts to wonder if this boy might be the one.
But Everett can’t forget the nameless boy with whom he shared one perfect night. He’s never seen one boy’s face and never got the other one’s name. How is he supposed to choose when he craves them both?
Santa might just give him everything he wants.
As long as another snap decision doesn’t destroy everything.