Beyond Compare by Ashley Logan

A man of few words, the boy next door and a girl trapped between now and then.
Katarina James has lusted after local grocer and hot single dad, Lennox Green since she moved to Buffalo. Equally infatuated, Lennox attempts to entice Kat into action, but all she does is run. To complicate matters further, Andy Coulson, the boy next door and unrequited love she lost to college is back – and he’s interested!
Generous to a fault when it comes to others, Kat refuses to satisfy any of her own desires. Doing so would mean sharing the shameful secret that threatens to destroy her family, her friends and her chances with the man she’s falling for.