All We Ever Wanted by Seth King

Their relationship is forbidden.
Their union would be shocking.
But their love? It’s undeniable…
Tommy Houston and James May are both nineteen when they are hired to sail a boat from Florida to Maine together.
Neither has ever been with another man before, and both come from highly traditional backgrounds. But as they sail up the coast, a sudden and overwhelming attraction explodes between them…
And over the next ten days on the open Atlantic, Tommy and James fall into a love so powerful, it comes to define both of their lives forever.
But how can they protect that love when their world wants nothing more than to pull them apart?